Shipping & Delivery
We bake every cheesecake in Chicago and ship it frozen, so it arrives as fresh as the day it was made. Here's how scheduling, shipping and delivery work.
Choosing Your Delivery Date
When you check out, you'll choose the day you'd like your order to arrive, up to 30 days ahead. We deliver Tuesday through Friday. We recommend choosing a date 1–2 days before your celebration. Need a date more than 30 days out? Call us at 1-800-ELI-CAKE and we'll schedule it for you.
Shipping Methods
After you pick a date, you'll see the shipping methods that can get your order there on time.
-
Standard: arrives on your selected date or up to 1 day early. Our cheesecakes ship frozen, so an early arrival can go right into the freezer.
-
Priority: arrives on your selected date.
If your date is close, Priority may be the only option.
Order Cutoff
Orders placed by 8 a.m. CT on a business day can ship that same day. Orders placed after 8am CT ship the next business day. The calendar only shows dates we can reach in time.
Shipping rates (per item)
|
Item |
Standard |
Priority |
|---|---|---|
|
Cheesecakes, layer cakes, Cuties, dippers |
$16.95 |
$49.95 |
|
Cheesecake boards, towers, party and multi-packs |
$23.95 |
$82.95 |
|
Mini pies, crispy bars, brownies, merch |
$10.95 |
$27.95 |
|
Cheesecake Club (3 / 6 / 12 months) |
$41.85 / $83.70 / $167.40 |
N/A |
When You're Charged
We place a temporary hold on your card when you order and charge it when your order ships. If you cancel before it ships, we release the hold.
How long a hold lasts depends on your card. Visa, Mastercard and American Express holds last up to 30 days. Discover and JCB holds last up to 10 days, and Diners Club and UnionPay holds last 7. If you're scheduling a delivery more than a week away, we recommend Visa, Mastercard or American Express. If your card's hold expires before we ship, we'll email you a link to confirm payment.
Delivery
FedEx delivers by 8pm local time. No one needs to be home. Packages may be left at the door, or at the office of an apartment building. Business addresses get weekday delivery only. College deliveries may need a signature, so give your student a heads-up.
Where We Ship
We ship to street addresses in the contiguous United States. We can't ship to PO boxes, APO/FPO addresses, Puerto Rico or outside the US. Orders to Alaska and Hawaii are by phone only: call 1-800-ELI-CAKE. Extra charges apply.
Sending to Several People
You can send to several addresses in one order. Each shipment gets its own delivery date and shipping method. Please check every address, and let each recipient know a frozen gift is on the way.
When it Arrives
Your order ships frozen in an insulated cooler with dry ice. It may arrive frozen, partly thawed or cool, and all of these are normal. Use gloves to remove any dry ice that's left, and never touch it with bare hands. Move your cheesecake to the freezer or fridge right away. [See how to store and serve it.]
Weather, Carriers and Other Delays
We work hard to deliver every order on time. Sometimes severe weather, carrier delays, holidays or dry ice shortages get in the way. If that happens, we may move your ship date to protect your order, and we'll let you know by email. We can't control carrier or weather delays, but if your order arrives late or not in perfect condition, we'll make it right.
If Something Goes Wrong
Contact us within 15 days of delivery. Please include:
-
your order number
-
the recipient's name
-
a photo of the product and the box
-
a short description of the problem
We'll send a replacement or a refund. Please don't return the product. We can't replace or refund orders sent to an incorrect address entered at checkout, or packages left unclaimed.
Changes and Cancellations
Need to change a date or address, or cancel? Contact us as soon as possible. Once an order ships, we can't change it.
Questions?
Email customerservice@elicheesecake.com or call 1-800-ELI-CAKE (1-800-354-2253), Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. CT except major holidays.
FAQ
Why can't I pick a Saturday, Sunday or Monday?
A package that sits in a warm truck over the weekend can thaw, so we only deliver Tuesday through Friday.
Why are some dates greyed out?
Those dates are a weekend, a Monday, a carrier holiday, or too soon for us to reach you. Try a later date, or choose Priority shipping.
Can I schedule more than 30 days ahead?
Yes. Call 1-800-ELI-CAKE and we'll set it up for you.
Why did my Standard order arrive a day early?
Standard orders can arrive up to 1 day before your date. Just pop the cheesecake in the freezer until the celebration. If you need the exact day, choose Priority.
When will my card be charged?
When your order ships. At checkout we only place a temporary hold on your card.
Which card should I use for a delivery weeks away?
Visa, Mastercard or American Express. Their holds last up to 30 days. Discover, JCB, Diners Club and UnionPay holds can expire after 7–10 days. If yours expires before we ship, we'll email you a link to confirm payment.
Can I send gifts to several people in one order?
Yes. Add each recipient in the cart. Each shipment gets its own delivery date and shipping method.
Do you ship to Alaska or Hawaii?
Yes, by phone only. Call 1-800-ELI-CAKE, Monday through Friday, 8am to 4pm CT. Extra charges apply.
Does someone need to be home?
No. FedEx leaves the package at the door. It ships in a cooler with dry ice, so bring it inside the same day.
How do I handle the dry ice?
For your safety, do not handle dry ice with your bare hands and keep away from children. Allow any remaining dry ice to evaporate in a well-ventilated area.
How do I store and serve my dessert?
Cheesecakes, Tres Leches Cake, Tiramisu:
- Thaw in fridge for at least 6 hours or, ideally, overnight.
- Serve chilled.
- Refrigerate for up to 5 days, or freeze up to 6 months
Layer Cakes, Mini Pies, and Dessert Bars:
- Thaw at room temp for at least 3 hours.
- Serve at room temp.
- Freeze up to 6 months
- Or store at room temp:
Choc. Chip Cookie Pies - 10 days
Cakes, Apple or Cherry Pies, Dessert Bars - 5 Days
Crispy Bars - 15 days
Dippers & Cheesecake Cuties:
- Store and serve frozen.
- Freeze up to 6 months
Uncut Cakes:
- Cheesecakes and layer cakes are best cut when partially frozen or very cold. Cut slices with a chef's knife, and wipe the blade after each cut.
My order arrived damaged or late. What should I do?
Contact us within 15 days. Send your order number, the recipient's name, a photo of the product and box, and a short description. We'll make it right.
Can I change my delivery date or address?
Yes, until your order ships. Email customerservice@elicheesecake.com or call 1-800-ELI-CAKE as soon as you can.