We ship nationwide!

Eli's Chicago-style Cheesecake, Desserts, and Gifts.
Eli's cheesecake logo

Shop Our Seasonal Desserts

A Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake with a slice being removed
Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake
$69
An Apple Streusel Cheesecake on a cake stand with a slice on a plate
Apple Streusel Cheesecake
$52
An overhead shot of a Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake, an Apple Streusel Cheesecake, and a Cranberry Orange Cheesecake.
Shop All Fall & Holiday Desserts
A cheesecake decorated with pecans with a chocolate plaque that reads "Happy Birthday Elana"
Design Your Own Cheesecake

Cart 0

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Sub total Free

You'll choose your delivery date at checkout. Sending gifts to more than one person? Choose Ship to Multiple Addresses.

Ship to multiple addresses

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout.

Your Cart is Empty

A slice of Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake

Original Plain Cheesecake

$60

A cheesecake decorated with sprinkles with a chocolate plaque that reads "Congratulations Haley and Abdul"

Design Your Own Custom Cheesecake

$75

Kosher

Filters

No filters available for this collection
A golden brown original plain cheesecake with a slice removed
 
A golden brown original plain cheesecake with a slice removed
A slice of Eli's Original Plain Cheesecake
Best Seller

Original Plain Cheesecake

Serves 16

From $51
A slice of Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath Toffee Bars, on a white plate
 
A slice of Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath Toffee Bars, on a white plate
A slice of Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath Toffee Bars, on a white plate

Candy Bar Cheesecake made with Heath® Toffee Bars

$65
A Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake with a slice being removed
 
A Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake with a slice being removed
A slice of Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake on a white plate with more slices in the background

Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake

Serves 14

$69
A chocolate chip cheesecake on a cake stand
 
A chocolate chip cheesecake on a cake stand
A chocolate chip cheesecake slice with a bite taken out
Best Seller

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

Serves 16

$60
A Hot Chocolate Cheesecake with a slice being removed
 
A Hot Chocolate Cheesecake with a slice being removed
A slice of Hot Chocolate Cheesecake

Hot Chocolate Cheesecake

Serves 14

$69
A sampler cheesecake with four different flavors: Original Plain, Candy Bar, Chocolate Chip, and Strawberry.
 
A sampler cheesecake with four different flavors: Original Plain, Candy Bar, Chocolate Chip, and Strawberry.
An overhead view of a sampler cheesecake with four different flavors: Original Plain, Candy Bar, Chocolate Chip, and Strawberry.
Best Seller

Original Favorites Cheesecake Sampler

Serves 16

$69
A Cookie Dough Cheesecake on a cake stand with a slice removed, with chocolate chip cookies in the background.
 
A Cookie Dough Cheesecake on a cake stand with a slice removed, with chocolate chip cookies in the background.
A slice of Cookie Dough Cheesecake on a plate with chocolate chip cookies in the background.

Cookie Dough Cheesecake

Serves 14

$69
Hands reaching out to take a dessert from Eli's cheesecake board, covered in many different varieties of cheesecake
 
Hands reaching out to take a dessert from Eli's cheesecake board, covered in many different varieties of cheesecake
Eli's cheesecake board, covered in many different varieties of cheesecake

Cheese(cake) Board Kit - Serves 12

Serves 12

$120
A photo of three cheesecakes: Original Plain, Strawberry, and Chocolate Chip
 

3 Month Cheesecake Club Subscription

$165
An Eli's Chicago-style Cheesecake Sampler on a cake stand, with its shipping box covered in Chicago-themed stickers.
 
An Eli's Chicago-style Cheesecake Sampler on a cake stand, with its shipping box covered in Chicago-themed stickers.
An Eli's Chicago-style Cheesecake Sampler on a cake stand with individual slices on plates, with its shipping box covered in Chicago-themed stickers.
New

Special Edition "Best Big City" Chicago-Style Sampler

Serves 12

$60
An Irish Coffee Cheesecake on a black plate with a slice removed
 
An Irish Coffee Cheesecake on a black plate with a slice removed
A slice of Irish Coffee Cheesecake on a black plate with a bite taken out

Irish Coffee Cheesecake

Serves 14

$69
A chocolate covered cheesecake with chocolate decorations and chocolate plaque that says "Happy Holidays"
 
A chocolate covered cheesecake with chocolate decorations and chocolate plaque that says "Happy Holidays"
A chocolate covered cheesecake with chocolate decorations and chocolate plaque that says "Happy Holidays"

Happy Holidays Cheesecake

Serves 12

$59
A chocolate peanut butter cheesecake with a slice removed
 
A chocolate peanut butter cheesecake with a slice removed
A slice of chocolate peanut butter cheesecake with peanut butter cups in the background
Sale

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake made with Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups

Serves 14

$52 $69
bite sized squares of chocolate cheesecake on a floral plate, decorated with chocolate shavings
 
bite sized squares of chocolate cheesecake on a floral plate, decorated with chocolate shavings
12 bite sized squares of chocolate cheesecake, decorated with chocolate shavings

Chocolate Cheesecake Cuties

$50
A box of individually-wrapped cheesecake brownies
 
A box of individually-wrapped cheesecake brownies
A brownie swirled with cheesecake, on a blue plate

Cheesecake Brownies - 12 Pack

Serves 12

$34
Individually-wrapped cheesecake brownies and chocolate chip cookie pies
 
Individually-wrapped cheesecake brownies and chocolate chip cookie pies
A brownie swirled with cheesecake, on a blue plate

Cheesecake Brownie and Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie Sampler

$34
An Apple Bavarian Tart on a green plate with a slice removed
 
An Apple Bavarian Tart on a green plate with a slice removed
A slice of Apple Bavarian Tart on a cake stand

Apple Bavarian Tart

Serves 12

$55
A layer cake topped with cocoa powder, with a slice of cake on a plate
 
A layer cake topped with cocoa powder, with a slice of cake on a plate
A slice of Tres Leches layer cake on a plate

Tres Leches Cake

Serves 14

$74
A tiramisu layer cake with cocoa being sprinkled on top
 
A tiramisu layer cake with cocoa being sprinkled on top
A slice of tiramisu layer cake
Best Seller Sale

Classic Italian Tiramisu Layer Cake

Serves 14

$55 $74
A strawberry cheesecake on a cake stand
 
A strawberry cheesecake on a cake stand
A slice of strawberry cheesecake being cut with a fork
Best Seller

Strawberry Cheesecake

Serves 14

$65